For a CEO with a retail banking background who hacked off entire business lines from the investment bank when he arrived, Christian Sewing at Deutsche Bank is now looking curiously dependent on precisely the division he set about to shrink.
A chart at the start of today's Deutsche Bank presentation underscores the new lopsided Deutsche Bank reality. Between the first quarter of 2020 and 2021, revenues at Deutsche Bank's investment bank rose by 35%. Over the same period, revenues in the corporate bank were flat and revenues in the private bank were flat. Over the past 12 months, revenues in most divisions were either flat or stable, except for the investment bank where they rose by 38%.
It's almost entirely thanks to the investment bank, then, that Deutsche can boast of strong revenue growth.
It's also thanks to the investment bank that Deutsche can boast of achieving a return on tangible equity in the core bank of nearly 11%, well above its target of 8% for 2022. In Deutsche's corporate and private banks, the return on equity was a miserable 6.3% in the first quarter. In the investment bank it was nearly 19%; in asset management it was higher still at 30%.
While the travails of the private and corporate banks are presented as transitory, Deutsche is convinced its investment bank will maintain its new pumped-up reality. "We continue to expect markets to normalize in the remainder of 2021, but we feel reassured in our view that a substantial portion of our investment bank growth since 2019 is sustainable. We now expect our revenues for 2021 to be very close to 2020 level," said Sewing today.
In other words, Deutsche's restructured investment bank is a new kind of creature. And by implication its strong revenue growth and this quarter's 66% year-on-year increase in profits are partly Sewing's own doing, given that he orchestrated the restructuring.
This might prove easier to argue if other banks weren't doing well. However, Deutsche's results today show that the investment bank is thriving in precisely the areas that rivals are thriving - and in some cases it's thriving a lot less.
The chart below shows the comparisons. Deutsche Bank doesn't do equities sales and trading nowadays, but its fixed income currencies and commodities (FICC) traders outperformed all but Morgan Stanley's in the first quarter. Its equity capital markets (ECM) bankers also outshone the market thanks to SPAC-fuelled year-on-year growth - but only because their first quarter in 2020 was so miserable. Meanwhile, Deutsche's advisory (M&A) and debt capital markets (DCM) bankers both lost share in Q1.
However much Sewing tells himself otherwise, then, Deutsche Bank's performance in the first quarter doesn't look all that special and won't necessarily prove sustainable when current conditions pass (Paul Taubman at PJT Partners yesterday predicted that the SPAC boom will be over soon). It was also mostly down to the one business Deutsche Bank always relied upon - and always tried to get away from when things don't go so well: fixed income trading. Within the investment bank, fixed income trading accounted for 80% of first quarter revenues. Within Deutsche Bank as a whole, fixed income trading was 35% of first quarter revenues. As long as fixed income trading keeps thriving, Sewing can keep sounding smug.
The danger for Deutsche is that it's now very reliant on one particular business area. Reading between the lines, it was credit trading in particular that drove revenues in the first quarter. - Deutsche said today that its rates, FX and emerging markets businesses didn't do so well. Deutsche's credit traders have a long history of driving strong revenues and profits, until things go wrong. Sewing today lauded Deutsche's "leading risk management capabilities;" hopefully he's right - in credit at least, the whole of Deutsche Bank is depending upon them.
Photo by Vance Osterhout on Unsplash
Have a confidential story, tip, or comment you’d like to share? Contact: email@example.com in the first instance. Whatsapp/Signal/Telegram also available.
Bear with us if you leave a comment at the bottom of this article: all our comments are moderated by human beings. Sometimes these humans might be asleep, or away from their desks, so it may take a while for your comment to appear. Eventually it will – unless it’s offensive or libelous (in which case it won’t.)