"Stay in banking too long, you'll be incapable of anything else"
I began my career in the investment banking division of a major European bank. Three years later, I left. Getting out of banking was the best decision I ever made.
It wasn't just about the working hours, although they were just as back-breaking as everyone says. Nor was it just about working with senior people who see you as dispensable - although they absolutely do. It was because the longer I stayed in banking, the more I could feel the industry crystallizing my bad habits and limiting my future career choices. I had to go.
Investment banking isn't about advice, it's about process
Investment banking is an advisory function. Or it's supposed to be. However, a lot of it is nothing more than processing market information when you're trying to win business, or managing a process on behalf of a client when you're trying to execute deals.
Most people in an investment banking division are not advisors. Only the most senior bankers are viewed as trusted advisors in the eyes of their clients - and they are a minority even among the seasoned managing director (MD) cohort. In my experience, most senior investment bankers are fighting between themselves to justify their expensive salaries in an ultra-competitive market. They rarely have an ability to form a long term view or stick to their beliefs (which would be the only way to gain the long term trust of their clients). They live by a “next quarter mentality” and when you're a junior this locks you into an endless cycle of processing and irrelevant analysis.
Senior bankers are slaves to clients, junior bankers are slaves to seniors
In investment banking, the client is king. The client can demand high speed turnaround of huge chunks of work. Senior bankers who want nothing more than to please clients will rarely push back on these unreasonable requests, so as a junior member of staff you are in for a lot of sleepless nights. You will learn very little - except to suppress all forms of initiative and free thought. Your main skill will become blind obedience to your clients and your seniors and if you're not careful you will perpetuate this by indoctrinating the juniors working below you when you become senior enough to do so.
Banking will make you a dreadful manager
Success in banking is all about processing. No one really cares about staff development when thousands of talented juniors are queuing to join the industry each year. The real goal is to squeeze everybody (especially the mid-level and junior cohorts) as much as physically possible to get all the processing done. Accepting this way of working - and the associated management style - as normal will have a hugely detrimental effect on your ability manage anyone in a more balanced environment where the pay is lower and managers actually have to motivate people.
You will learn nothing about the detail of finance
Working in banking is all about high level analysis. You're not going to be doing any detailed work because you won't have the knowledge, the information or the time. When you're a junior banker, a leverage ratio becomes nothing more than “3.5x” - the whole rich world behind this number (debt covenants, structural subordination, the security package, the acceleration rights) is lost. Ignoring this world is in effect ignoring the inner workings of corporate finance itself. But ignore it you will.
There will be unknown unknowns that you'll only discover when you walk away
When I was a junior banker, I worked worked on large and small deals but I never saw a loan agreement or a term sheet. There are a lot of key work streams that investment bankers simply don’t deal with. These include negotiating legal work, supporting post-merger integration, or developing strategies for business restructuring. If you work in a finance job in the corporate sector or in private equity, you'll need these skills. In banking, you won't develop them at all.
Of course, not all banking jobs are this bad and some people in banking are extremely knowledgeable and well-rounded individuals. In my experience, however, they are in the minority. For me, banking started my career but it was threatening to become a blocker unless I left before I became enmeshed in the system. I left last year. I'm very glad I did.
Aron Woods is the pseudonym of a former analyst at a European bank
Have a confidential story, tip, or comment you’d like to share? Contact: firstname.lastname@example.org in the first instance. Whatsapp/Signal/Telegram also available.
Bear with us if you leave a comment at the bottom of this article: all our comments are moderated by human beings. Sometimes these humans might be asleep, or away from their desks, so it may take a while for your comment to appear. Eventually it will – unless it’s offensive or libelous (in which case it won’t.)
Photo by Joe Stubbs on Unsplash